To the Editor:

“What Makes a Woman?” (Sunday Review, June 7) is in line with a growing emergence of tired, second-wave feminist critiques of Caitlyn Jenner’s decision to finally become the woman she is. If Elinor Burkett spends even a moment with a trans person or advocacy group, she will quickly learn that the “born into the wrong body” rhetoric is simply a poor translation of the truth, a phrase crafted for mainstream consumption of an otherwise nuanced notion that gender, and even biological sex, are social constructs. The landscape that’s being mapped out is hard to understand and navigate only if you’re holding onto old notions of feminism.

Ms. Jenner has every right to be as beautiful and superficial as she wants, regardless of the male privilege she benefited from previously, or the feminine beauty ideal she conforms to now, because that’s the culture we want to live in—one in which we’re all free to express our individual truths.

ALLISON H. STEINBERG
New York

The writer is an L.G.B.T. communications professional.

Note from KBJ: Biological sex is a social construct? How so? From the fact that there are hard cases (i.e., cases of hermaphroditism) it doesn't follow that there are no easy cases. Analogy: There are times each day when it's not clear whether it's day or night; therefore, there is no difference between day and night. Only someone who is logically challenged (or in the grip of ideology) could commit such an egregious error.

Note 2 from KBJ: Someone needs to say it, so I will. Most feminists despise attractive women. It's called resentment. If I can't have what you have, I will (1) pretend that it's not worth having and (2) attack your intellect and your character for wanting it. Ever hear of false consciousness? It's what feminists say normal women suffer from, simply because they enjoy being women and refuse to view themselves as victims. Feminism needs victims (in the same way that race hustlers and shakedown artists such as Jesse Jackson and Al Sharpton need victims). Here's the recipe: Take ordinary, healthy people; persuade them that they're being victimized by men (or whites); offer to lead them to utopia. If, in addition to creating victims, you can persuade men (or whites) to feel guilty, you can make a good living. Is this a great country, or what?